Jump directly to the content

Peyton Manning is the perfect reminder of the power of a No. 1 NFL Draft pick.

But top selections rarely become the best players and there have been some serious busts in league history.

JaMarcus Russell had a huge arm but it quickly went downhill after he went No. 1
4
JaMarcus Russell had a huge arm but it quickly went downhill after he went No. 1Credit: Getty

While Tony Mandarich is widely considered to be the biggest bust of all time, the former Green Bay offensive lineman was a No. 2 pick in 1989.

Ryan Leaf, another huge draft bust, was taken second in 1998, one spot behind Manning.

When it comes to the biggest bust as a No. 1 pick, that award is reserved for a quarterback who was supposed to be a franchise-changer but ended up barely playing for the franchise that drafted him.

JaMarcus Russell was a prized No. 1 pick for the Oakland Raiders in 2007.

READ MORE ON NFL

"The skill level he has is certainly John Elway-like," ESPN draft analyst Mel Kiper said.

And 17 years later, Russell is almost forgotten by NFL fans, despite receiving a huge $61 million contract.

"It has been a long time and I am happy that everything is finally over and I get a chance to be a football player again," said Russell, after a tense holdout finally ended.

At the time, the former LSU QB signed the richest rookie deal in NFL history.

Russell fell out of favor with the Raiders and slid down the depth chart
4
Russell fell out of favor with the Raiders and slid down the depth chartCredit: Getty
His weight became an issue in the pros while his off-the-field issues mounted
4
His weight became an issue in the pros while his off-the-field issues mountedCredit: Getty

But it never went right for the 6ft 6in and 265lb Russell in the pros and, in many ways, things only got worse.

Russell's lengthy holdout forced him to miss critical practice time.

NFL executive Bill Tobin fights with ESPN draft analyst Mel Kiper on live TV during heated interview

As a result, he only played in four games (one start) as a rookie with the Raiders in 2007.

His stats were also off target. Russell only completed 54.5 per cent of his passes with two touchdowns and four interceptions.

Turnover problems plagued the ex-Tiger -- Russell finished his NFL career with more picks (23) than TDs (18) -- and he completed less than 50 percent of his pass attempts during his last year in the pros.

But off-the-field issues were even more problematic.

Russell regularly appeared overweight -- he reportedly approached 300 pounds -- while questions lingered about his willingness to study the Raiders' playbook.

The former No. 1 pick quickly fell out of favor in Oakland, falling down the depth chart and struggling to stay on the field.

Russell's football career peaked in college at LSU
4
Russell's football career peaked in college at LSUCredit: Getty

From 2007-09, Russell went 7-18 as a starter.

During his final season in the pros, he threw 11 interceptions compared to just three TDs.

A year later, Russell was arrested and charged with possession of a controlled substance - codeine syrup.

He finished his NFL career with a 52.1 completion percentage and 131.7 passing yards per game.

“I didn’t feel like they were there for me," said Russell, describing his football relationship with the Raiders.

Russell told ESPN in 2010 that he had tested positive for codeine after becoming the Raiders' No. 1 pick, and acknowledged using codeine without a prescription.

The former LSU star attempted to find his way back into the NFL and make a come back, but a path never materialized.

He had let the Raiders down, then become untouchable across the league.

The 38-year-old only played three seasons in the pros and is still considered to be the worst No. 1 pick of all time.

The NFL Draft keeps getting larger and larger — and so do the crowds.

What used to occur in a hotel room with names written on a blackboard has become a massive three-day event televised on multiple networks at once.

Read More on talkSPORT

More than 275,000 fans attended the first round on Thursday in downtown Detroit, watching Caleb Williams go No. 1 overall to the Chicago Bears and the Atlanta Falcons stun the league by drafting Michael Penix Jr., after recently signing veteran quarterback Kirk Cousins to a $180 million contract.

The huge crowd set a NFL Draft record, breaking the all-time day one mark of 200,000 set in 2019 by Nashville, Tenn.​

Topics